Two pins, two collecting paths
The Vox Machina Crest Pin No. 2 and the Mollymauk Tealeaf Chibi Pin No. 9 sit in different corners of the Critical Role pin lineup. One is a faction emblem from the main pin series; the other is a character portrait from the Chibi series. If you are choosing between them, the real question is whether you want a campaign symbol or a character piece. Both are gold- or silver-plated zinc alloy with enamel and an embossed Critical Role logo on the back, so the decision comes down to design language, series continuity, and how you plan to wear or display the pin.
What each pin confirms
- Critical Role Pin No. 2 - Vox Machina Crest: Pin #2 in the Critical Role Pin series, gold plated zinc alloy with soft enamel, embossed Critical Role logo on the back. Tells you this is a main-series crest pin with a warm gold finish and soft enamel fill.

Critical Role Pin No. 2 - Vox Machina Crest - Critical Role Pin No. 2 - Vox Machina Crest: Design: redesigned crest of Vox Machina, heroes of Tal’Dorei. Confirms the pin is a campaign emblem rather than a character portrait.
- Critical Role Chibi Pin No. 9 - Mollymauk Tealeaf: Pin #9 of the Chibi Pin series, silver plated zinc alloy with hard enamel, embossed Critical Role logo on the back. Shows this is a later entry in the chibi line with a cooler silver finish and hard enamel surface.

Critical Role Chibi Pin No. 9 - Mollymauk Tealeaf - Critical Role Chibi Pin No. 9 - Mollymauk Tealeaf: Designed by Critter Jenny Park (@asunnydisposish), featuring Mollymauk’s cloak, tarot cards, and smirk. Highlights the fan-artist connection and the specific character details packed into the chibi format.
Crest pin vs chibi pin: the practical differences
- Series and numbering: The Crest Pin is #2 in the main Critical Role Pin series; the Mollymauk pin is #9 in the Chibi Pin series. If you are building a numbered run, each belongs to a different set, so check which series you are closer to completing.
- Material and finish: Crest Pin: gold plated zinc alloy with soft enamel. Mollymauk Chibi Pin: silver plated zinc alloy with hard enamel. The gold/soft combination tends to read warmer and slightly more textured; the silver/hard combination tends to read cooler and smoother. Neither is inherently better—pick the finish that matches the rest of your collection or your usual metal accessories.
- Design focus: The Crest Pin is a redesigned Vox Machina crest—a symbol of the group. The Mollymauk pin is a character chibi with cloak, tarot cards, and smirk. Choose the crest if you want campaign iconography; choose Mollymauk if you want a recognizable character moment.
- Artist credit: The Mollymauk Chibi Pin record names Critter Jenny Park (@asunnydisposish) as designer. The Crest Pin record does not name an individual designer in the supplied information. If fan-artist credit matters to you, that is a point in the chibi pin’s favor.
- Price: Catalog price for the Crest Pin is USD 7.29 (comparison price USD 9.99); the Mollymauk Chibi Pin is USD 7.80 (comparison price USD 10.99). The difference is small, so let design and series fit drive the decision rather than the extra few cents.
Size: what the records actually say
The supplied records list the Crest Pin as 1.5" and the Mollymauk Chibi Pin as 1.75". Those are the only measurements provided; do not infer wearability or visual weight beyond them. If you need exact dimensions for a display case or a specific garment, use those figures as your reference and measure your space accordingly. The records do not include backing type, closure style, or care instructions, so treat any cleaning or storage advice as general enamel-pin practice rather than manufacturer guidance.
Which pin fits your collection better?
- You are collecting the main pin series: The Vox Machina Crest Pin No. 2 is the clear pick. It advances a numbered main-series set and gives you a campaign emblem that pairs naturally with other Vox Machina merchandise.
- You are collecting chibi character pins: The Mollymauk Tealeaf Chibi Pin No. 9 is the better fit. It continues the chibi line and adds a fan-designed character piece with distinct costume details.
- You want a single pin to wear on a jacket or bag: Both work, but consider finish: gold/soft enamel reads warmer and slightly more casual; silver/hard enamel reads cooler and more polished. The size difference (1.5" vs 1.75") is modest and may not matter on a lapel or canvas bag.
- You are buying a gift for a Critical Role fan: If the recipient’s favorite campaign is Vox Machina, the Crest Pin is a safe symbolic choice. If they love Mollymauk or the Mighty Nein, the chibi pin carries more personal character detail. When unsure, the crest is the more neutral option.
What the records do not confirm
Neither record supplies care instructions, backing type, or compatibility details. That means you should not assume a specific clasp style or cleaning method from these pages. For enamel pins generally, avoid soaking and harsh abrasives, but treat that as common practice, not a manufacturer instruction for these specific pins. If you need confirmed care guidance, check the packaging or the store’s product page for updates. The absence of that information here is a limitation of the supplied evidence, not a sign that the pins lack standard features.



